As a citizen of Virginia, it is important to understand the laws and regulations governing attorney’s fees and expenses. One such regulation that affects all residents of Virginia, is the "American Rule" governing the payment of attorney’s fees. This rule lays out the conditions for the payment of attorney’s fees and expenses in any legal proceeding where the plaintiff has not won the case.
Table of Contents
What Is The American Rule?
The American Rule is a legal principle that governs the payment of attorney’s fees in litigation. Unlike the English Rule which allows the winning party to recover attorney’s fees from the losing party, the American Rule states that each party is responsible for paying their own attorney’s fees and expenses in most cases. This means that even if a plaintiff wins a case, they cannot always recover their attorney’s fees and expenses from the defendant.
Exceptions to the American Rule
Despite being the general rule in Virginia, there are some exceptions to the American Rule. The following are some of the exceptions:
Statutory exceptions
Statutory exceptions are those exceptions written in the law. This means that Virginia law allows the recovery of attorney’s fees and expenses in certain cases, such as:
- Contractual disputes: In Virginia, parties can recover attorney’s fees that are related to enforcing or interpreting the terms of a contract.
- Discrimination cases: If an employer is found guilty of discrimination, the employee can recover attorney’s fees and expenses.
- Patent, Copyright and Trademark Infringement Lawsuits: In certain situations, a winner in a patent, copyright or trademark infringement lawsuit can recover attorney’s fees.
Procedural Exceptions
Procedural exceptions are those exceptions created by the courts. These exceptions are applied to situations where one party behaves unreasonably or improperly. Procedural exceptions to the American Rule in Virginia may include:
- Rule 11 Sanctions: Rule 11 of the federal rules of Civil Procedure allows a judge to impose sanctions and a possible award of attorney’s fees and expenses where an attorney files a pleading or other paper in bad faith.
- Frivolous litigation: In some situations, if a party files a frivolous lawsuit, the court may impose sanctions and award attorney’s fees.
- Bad Faith conduct: Where one party acts in bad faith, the court may award attorney’s fees to the other party.
Conclusion
In Virginia, the American Rule is the general rule governing the payment of attorney’s fees in litigation. However, this rule is not absolute and can be subject to exceptions. As such, it is important to consult with an experienced attorney when entering into any litigation in Virginia, to ensure that you are fully aware of the rules governing attorney’s fees and other costs associated with the litigation. If you have any questions about Virginia law and the payment of attorney’s fees, consult a licensed attorney in Virginia who can provide legal advice and guidance.